Next story

Judge denies CFTC bid to block New York enforcement against Kalshi

A state court will consider New York's request to restrict Kalshi's sports event contracts at a hearing on Monday, November 23.

A courthouse and a trading screen separated by a judge's gavel.
Illustration: Gembly (AI-generated)

A federal judge on Friday denied the Commodity Futures Trading Commission's emergency request to block New York from pursuing enforcement against prediction market operator Kalshi, leaving a state court hearing scheduled for Monday, November 23.

U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield found that the CFTC had not established a likelihood of success on its argument that federal law prevents states from applying gambling regulations to federally regulated prediction markets, Gambling Insider reported.

The New York County Supreme Court will consider Attorney General Letitia James' request for a temporary restraining order to prevent Kalshi from offering sports event contracts in the state. New York's lawsuit alleges that Kalshi has conducted unlicensed gambling in violation of state law.

The federal ruling followed a decision one day earlier returning the enforcement lawsuit against Kalshi to state court. In its November 20 emergency filing, the CFTC argued that the proposed state order could effectively shut down Kalshi nationwide because the company's headquarters are in New York.

The proposed order would prohibit Kalshi from operating “within or from” New York. Kalshi also warned that the language could affect customers and trading activity across the U.S.

Schofield noted that three appellate courts have ruled against Kalshi and one has ruled in its favor, producing conflicting decisions on whether the Commodity Exchange Act preempts state gambling regulations. Kalshi maintains that its products are federally regulated derivatives under the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction.

In a November 19 letter, Kalshi asked the state court not to issue an order before hearing both sides. The company also said the order would conflict with an August CFTC directive requiring it to continue operating its exchange even if a court ordered it to block New York.

New York's November 20 response accused Kalshi of delaying enforcement while continuing to profit from New York customers. The attorney general's office said its request would stop unlicensed gambling products, not shut down Kalshi nationwide, and noted that Kalshi allows users under 21 to wager on sports, including New York college teams, which state sports betting laws prohibit.

  • Kalshi
  • CFTC
  • New York
  • Prediction markets
  • Sports betting
Next storyLoterie Romande seeks CEO as Jean-Luc Moner-Banet plans retirement