Next story

Federal judge sends New York’s Kalshi enforcement case back to state court

Judge Vernon Broderick found that the state’s claims did not require interpretation of the Commodity Exchange Act. Kalshi has asked for a prompt status conference.

A courthouse and legal papers beside a trading screen.
Illustration: Gembly (AI-generated)

A federal judge has sent New York’s enforcement lawsuit against prediction market operator Kalshi back to state court, rejecting the company’s arguments that the case belongs in federal court.

Attorney General Letitia James filed the lawsuit in July, alleging that Kalshi operates an unlicensed gambling business in violation of New York law, Gambling Insider reported. Kalshi had moved the case to federal court, citing its status as an exchange regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and the federal legal questions it said were involved.

U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick granted New York’s request to return the case to state court. He found that the state-law claims do not require interpretation of the Commodity Exchange Act and that Kalshi’s reliance on federal authorization was a defense to the allegations, not a basis for federal jurisdiction.

Broderick also pointed to states’ longstanding authority to regulate gambling. He agreed with an earlier New York federal court ruling that the Commodity Exchange Act leaves room for states to exercise those powers.

Kalshi responded with a letter to the state Supreme Court, asking it to reject any renewed application for a temporary restraining order and requesting a prompt status conference.

Separately, Kalshi and fellow prediction market operator Novig sent a joint letter to 35 states seeking access to gambling self-exclusion databases, Gambling Insider reported, citing Bloomberg. The lists contain the names of people who have voluntarily excluded themselves from regulated gambling.

The operators’ attorneys wrote that separate state lists leave gaps for people at risk, according to the letter reviewed by Bloomberg News. Both companies have implemented their own self-exclusion tools while continuing to dispute state oversight of certain event contracts.

  • Kalshi
  • New York
  • Prediction markets
  • Gambling regulation
  • Self-exclusion
Next storyBally’s Intralot reports record UK and Spain online results in Q3