Next story
High Court ruling narrows route to gambling negligence claims, lawyer says
The court dismissed a claim brought by Luke Ashton's widow, finding insufficient evidence that Betfair's operator knew or should have known of the relevant risk.

A High Court ruling dismissing a negligence claim against Betfair's betting exchange operator has narrowed the circumstances in which gambling companies can be held responsible for knowing about a customer's disorder, a lawyer told iGaming Business.
Judge Swift dismissed the claim against TSE Malta LP on Friday 13th November. Ann-Marie Ashton had brought the case after her husband, Luke Ashton, died by suicide in 2021 at age 40.
The family argued that Betfair failed to identify and respond to Ashton's gambling, worsening his condition and contributing to his death. The judge found insufficient evidence that Ashton had a gambling disorder or that the company knew, or ought to have known, he faced the relevant risk.
Bethan Lloyd, a partner at Wiggin Law, told iGaming Business that the decision was more significant for limiting claims based on what operators should have inferred from customer data than for opening the way to more litigation.
The judge held that an operator could owe a duty of care to prevent severe gambling disorder when the risk was foreseeable. Lloyd said that could arise when an operator knows of a diagnosis or a customer's behavior is so extreme that it shows gambling is wholly outside their control.
The court also considered the Gambling Act 2005 and Gambling Commission requirements for interventions. It found that regulatory obligations alone did not provide a suitable basis for a civil negligence claim and rejected an implied contractual term requiring compliance with the commission's Licence Conditions and Codes of Practice.
The court heard that Ashton gambled every day between 20 and 30 March, averaging 64 bets a day and spending at least four hours daily on the site. Betfair sent him four automated safer-gambling messages during March, directing him to tools including limits, time-outs and self-exclusion.
His family argued that Betfair should have contacted him directly rather than assessing his activity partly against patterns across a wider customer base. A Flutter UKI spokesperson told iGaming Business: “While we welcome the court’s ruling, this is a tragic case and we once again offer our sincere condolences to Mrs Ashton and her family.”
Lloyd said claimants would still face difficulties establishing that one operator caused harm, particularly if a customer had gambled with multiple companies. She said the ruling was nevertheless notable for establishing that a duty of care could extend to psychiatric injury, not just repayment of losses.