Next story
CFTC sports contract proposal draws 140 comments as tribal groups oppose rule
A coalition of 43 states and Washington, D.C., joined tribal organizations in opposing the proposal. Three tribes partnered with Kalshi supported federal oversight.

A US Commodity Futures Trading Commission proposal to include sports event contracts in the definition of swaps received 140 public comments by the November 18 deadline, with tribal organizations leading opposition and prediction-market companies backing federal oversight.
Most submissions arrived in the final two days of the comment period, Gambling Insider reported. The total was below the over 3,500 comments received on an April advance notice of proposed rulemaking and the over 1,400 submitted on a July proposal.
The latest proposal addresses whether event contracts qualify as swaps, rather than setting out comprehensive trading rules. Opponents include a coalition of 43 states and Washington, D.C., the American Gaming Association and Rep. Dina Titus of Nevada.
The National Congress of American Indians, which represents approximately 300 tribal nations, called for the proposal to be withdrawn. It argued that Congress did not intend the CFTC to regulate gambling.
Simply labeling these wagers as swaps does not change their underlying nature as gambling.
Other tribal opponents included the California Nations Indian Gaming Association, Oklahoma Indian Gaming Association and Arizona Indian Gaming Association. The Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria warned that sports event contracts threatened tribal governments’ economic foundations.
Three of the four tribes that partnered with Kalshi in October took a different position. Alabama-Quassarte Tribal Town argued that federal event-contract regulation and tribal gaming could coexist, while Alturas Indian Rancheria and Greenville Rancheria backed regulatory certainty and tribal participation in financial markets. Kletsel Dehe Wintun Nation did not submit a comment.
The state coalition argued that the CFTC lacked statutory authority to redefine sports wagering as financial derivatives. In a separate letter, Utah Gov. Spencer Cox and Attorney General Derek Brown raised concerns about gambling addiction, household financial harm and state regulatory authority.
Kalshi, Polymarket US, Coinbase, Gemini and Underdog were among the companies supporting inclusion of event contracts in the swap definition. Gemini also recommended changes, including clearer statutory boundaries and documentation of the SEC’s participation.
The CFTC will consider the submissions as it decides whether to revise or finalize the proposal.