Next story
Fourth Circuit rules for Maryland in Kalshi sports contracts case
The 2-1 decision leaves the underlying lawsuit unresolved. Maryland regulators had accused Kalshi of offering sports wagering without a state license.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled for Maryland on November 17, upholding the denial of Kalshi’s request for a preliminary injunction against state gambling enforcement over its sports event contracts.
The court voted 2-1 to affirm a U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland decision, InGame reported. Judges Roger Gregory and Stephanie Thacker agreed on the outcome for different reasons, while Judge Benjamin dissented.
Maryland regulators issued Kalshi a cease-and-desist letter in April 2025, arguing that it offered sports wagering without a state license, according to Covers. The appellate decision does not resolve the underlying lawsuit.
Gregory concluded that the Commodity Exchange Act does not displace Maryland’s gambling authority, even assuming the contracts qualify as swaps. He did not decide whether they are swaps and said Kalshi could comply with both federal and state requirements, Gambling Insider reported.
Thacker concluded that the contracts are not swaps and therefore fall outside the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s exclusive jurisdiction. She reasoned that payment depends on the result of a completed sporting event, rather than whether an event occurs.
Benjamin argued that sports contracts are swaps and that federal law preempts Maryland’s gambling laws. She distinguished contracts tied to sporting outcomes from parlays and prop bets, which she said lacked sufficient economic consequences to qualify as swaps.
A Kalshi spokesperson told InGame that the opinions showed judges could not agree on a single legal argument against prediction markets. Kalshi could ask for a hearing by the full appeals court or appeal to the Supreme Court, the outlet reported.
Maryland had agreed not to enforce its gambling laws against Kalshi until the Fourth Circuit ruled. The state may now sue Kalshi in state court and seek to ban its sports contracts, according to InGame.
Other federal appeals courts have reached different conclusions. The Third Circuit ruled for Kalshi in New Jersey, while the Sixth and Ninth Circuits rejected its arguments in cases involving Ohio, Tennessee and Nevada, Gambling Insider reported.
New Jersey asked the Supreme Court in September to review the Third Circuit decision. Kalshi’s response is due Dec. 7 after the company requested more time, InGame reported. Covers reported that the Supreme Court has not agreed to hear the underlying dispute.
In Louisiana, federal Judge Lance Africk ordered the consolidation of the CFTC’s lawsuit and Louisiana’s removed state lawsuit into Polymarket’s federal complaint on November 16. Kalshi separately dismissed its preemptive lawsuit against Louisiana officials without prejudice.